Tibitha Matheney

Experience You Can Trust. Results You Can Count On.

For more than two decades, Tibitha Matheney has been a trusted REALTOR® throughout the Mahoning Valley and Northeast Ohio, providing experienced representation, honest guidance and personal service from beginning to end.

A lifelong Mahoning Valley resident and full-time REALTOR® since 2003, Tibitha is nearing 2,000 career home sales and has experience with virtually every type of residential transaction—from first-time purchases and investment properties to longtime family homes and luxury estates.

Known for her strong negotiation skills, market knowledge and steady approach, Tibitha takes the time to understand each client’s goals and creates a strategy tailored to their needs. Whether buying, selling, relocating, investing or navigating a major life transition, her clients benefit from thoughtful guidance and experienced representation every step of the way.

Her success is reflected in more than two decades of top-producer recognition, including CENTURION® Producer awards and national recognition among the Top 50 CENTURY 21 individual agents. As a Seniors Real Estate Specialist® (SRES®), she also provides specialized guidance for clients and families navigating downsizing, relocation and other important transitions.

Beyond her own clients, Tibitha co-owns the Canfield office of CENTURY 21 Lakeside Realty, mentors real estate professionals and stays actively involved in the local community. Her greatest accomplishment, however, is the lasting relationships she has built with clients—many of whom return for their next move or refer family and friends.

Whether you’re buying your first home, selling a luxury property, investing or planning your next chapter, Tibitha brings the experience, judgment and personal attention to help you move forward with confidence.