"You welcomed us with open arms, and serving you during this time has been the greatest privilege."
That was Anna's Cookin' saying goodbye to Austintown in July. Anna Rodriguez opened her Puerto Rican takeout spot at 4750 Mahoning Ave. in 2021. After five years she announced a move to another state, and July 29, 2026 was the last day. The storefront hasn't stayed empty long. Another kitchen that has been feeding the Valley for years already has plans for it.
Several new names are going up on Mahoning Avenue this fall. A few of them are national chains, and they're getting most of the attention. The more interesting change is at two buildings with long restaurant histories. Both are being taken over by Valley-grown food businesses that are opening storefronts for the first time in Austintown.
4750 Mahoning Avenue goes from takeout to barbecue by the pound
The new tenant at the old Anna's Cookin' space is 330 BBQ and Catering. Owner Scott Davis told WFMJ he's aiming to open in late October or early November. Davis describes 330 BBQ as a southern-style barbecue catering business that has been around for decades. If you've eaten at a graduation party, office lunch or reception around here, there's a fair chance you've already had their food.
The Austintown storefront is a brick-and-mortar home for the business. Davis says meat will be ordered by the pound and sliced in front of you, Texas style, with their usual sides. You'll be able to eat in, order at the counter or take it home, and the catering side will keep running.
The building has turned over before. When Business Journal Daily profiled Anna's Cookin' in December 2021, the article noted that the space had been a pizza shop before she moved in. So that's three local kitchens in the same room in about five years: pizza, then Puerto Rican takeout, now a caterer opening a restaurant. None of them has been a chain.
Puerto Rican food moves down the road to the former Upstairs building
Austintown didn't lose Puerto Rican food when Anna's Cookin' closed. It's moving to a different spot on the same road.
On July 29, 2026, the same day Anna's Cookin' closed, brothers Jonathan, Carmelo and Jeremy Morales announced that their fourth Red Rican restaurant will open at 4500 Mahoning Ave. That's the building longtime Valley diners know as the Upstairs. WKBN reported that the brothers started Red Rican with a single food truck about three years earlier. The family moved from the Bronx to Youngstown in the mid-1990s. Their father opened a pizza shop on the East Side, and Puerto Rican dishes slowly took over more of his menu. WFMJ lists the menu as pastelillos, mofongo, sandwiches, rice bowls and tres leches cake.
No opening date had been announced as of that July report. WKBN even updated its story to correct an earlier version that suggested otherwise. The same report included a detail that matters for Austintown. The brothers expect their next locations, and the ones after those, to be somewhere outside the Mahoning Valley. That would make Austintown the last Valley storefront for a while from a business that started here.
The building has had a lot of changes in two years. In 2024, Prima Cucina moved from downtown Youngstown into the former Upstairs space. The owners remodeled and added a rooftop patio above the ground floor. The Austintown location closed in July 2025. That October, the building and land at 4496 Mahoning Ave. sold for $550,000 to RAA Ventures LLC of Canfield, according to Mahoning County Auditor records reported by Business Journal Daily. Send It Packin, a FedEx and UPS shipping outlet, is also a tenant in the building. The sale record and the Red Rican announcement use slightly different street numbers, 4496 and 4500. That fits a building with more than one address, so it's safest to say Red Rican is coming to the old Upstairs building, not to Prima's exact space.
Where the national names are going
The other openings on the corridor this fall look different. These brands are opening in shopping plazas or building new.
| Business | Address | Status as reported |
|---|---|---|
| Jersey Mike's Subs | 5536 Mahoning Ave. | Opened Sept. 23, 2026; open daily 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. |
| 7 Brew | Mahoning and Howard avenues | New 500-square-foot drive-through stand; opening set for Oct. 12, open daily 5:30 a.m. to 11 p.m. |
| Capriotti's Sandwich Shop | 4769 Mahoning Ave., Marc's Plaza by Idaho Road | Planned for sometime in November |
| Neighborhood Swing | Falcon Commons Plaza, Mahoning and Evans avenues | 24/7 indoor golf simulator; interior work underway, no opening date |
Jersey Mike's tied its grand opening to a fundraiser for Austintown Fitch athletics. Capriotti's is hiring shift leaders, grill cooks and sandwich makers, and they'll train at the chain's Canfield and Niles shops. Austintown Zoning Inspector Dominic Moltchen confirmed the Neighborhood Swing location. He didn't have a timeline, but said Mahoning County Building Inspection was working on the interior.
Look at the addresses. Capriotti's at 4769 and 330 BBQ at 4750 are 19 numbers apart. If both open on schedule, a national sandwich chain and a local barbecue counter will start serving on nearly the same block within a few weeks of each other.
The biggest plaza on the road changed hands too. Business Journal Daily reported in September that a Massachusetts LLC had paid $6.4 million for a 4.52-acre piece of Austintown Plaza at 6000 Mahoning Ave. That parcel includes Planet Fitness and Fun City Adventure Park. The report covered the ownership change only. It didn't mention any new tenants, so for now you'll see the same signs there.
The fall calendar for this stretch
Here's what's on the calendar, based on what's been announced, for anyone keeping track of the corridor over the next few weeks:
- Sunday, Oct. 4: Pink Out Mahoning Valley at Austintown Township Park, 6000 Kirk Road, with 18 local bands and more than 30 vendors and concession trucks.
- Monday, Oct. 12: 7 Brew's scheduled opening at Mahoning and Howard.
- Saturday, Oct. 24, noon to 3 p.m.: Gateways to Better Living's free Not So Haunted House at Austintown Plaza, next to the Post Office.
- Late October or early November: 330 BBQ's target opening at 4750 Mahoning Ave.
- November: Capriotti's planned opening in Marc's Plaza.
- Date not yet announced: Red Rican at the former Upstairs building, and Neighborhood Swing at Falcon Commons Plaza.
All of these opening dates are plans the businesses shared with local reporters. Restaurant timelines tend to slip with inspections and build-outs, so it's a good idea to check each business's own page before you drive over hungry.
A storefront changing hands is one of the clearest signs of how a road like Mahoning Avenue is doing, and I've watched these corners turn over for more than twenty years as a Valley resident and REALTOR. If you're curious what the new tenants at 4750 or the old Upstairs building could mean for your own Austintown home, I'm always glad to talk it through. Let's Connect with Tibitha Matheney.