At The Landings at Boulder Creek, Joe Koch Construction's wooded development off New Road beside Heron's Landing, $90,000 buys a homesite this fall. The house costs extra. Five lots in the community's second phase are listed at that price, and the builder is taking deposits on them.
That number matters to anyone weighing a new build against an existing home, because it shows up early on paper and late in the budget. A buyer who sees "$90,000" next to a new Austintown address is looking at the land alone. The house, the site work and everything else a builder quotes go on top of it.
When you compare that land price with what homes actually sell for in Mahoning County, it tells you who new construction here is built for. It also shows how it can still help a buyer who never plans to build.
What many may not realize, when deciding to buy or build, having a trusted Realtor by your side is something that can be utilized throughout the entire multifaceted process. Reach out and connect with trusted professional and Austintown Resident, Tibitha Matheney, for an initial consultation to begin.
What is actually for sale on the builder's side
Austintown's new construction right now comes almost entirely from one local builder, at three sites in different stages.
Community | Location | Where it stands | Listed price |
|---|---|---|---|
The Landings at Boulder Creek | Off New Road, next to Heron's Landing | 15 homes built in phase one as of March 2026, phase two now available | Five lots at $90,000 each |
Lloyd Oaks | Former Lloyd Elementary School site, Fitch and Norquest boulevards | WFMJ reports construction underway, no completion timeframe | Three 80 by 165 foot lots at $50,000 each |
Route 46 subdivision | Along State Route 46 near Chipper's Practice Range | Reported in March 2026 as a plan for roughly 100 houses | No lots listed |
The Lloyd Oaks site was described in March as four houses on the former school property. WFMJ's report on the start of construction said crews and equipment were on site at Fitch and Norquest. It also said there was no definite timeframe for when the homes would be finished. The Route 46 subdivision is the largest of the three and has the fewest public details. It is a plan a builder described to The Business Journal, not a community with lots for sale.
Lot listings come from the builder's live pages and change as lots sell. Check current availability on Joe Koch Construction's Landings page and Lloyd Oaks page.
The land math against the resale market
According to MLS Now figures reported by The Business Journal, the average home sold in Mahoning County in August 2026 went for $260,181. That is a countywide average covering every community, not an Austintown figure. Still, it is the closest current benchmark for what an existing home costs in the area.
Against that benchmark:
- A Landings lot at $90,000 costs about 35% of the August 2026 county average sale.
- A Lloyd Oaks lot at $50,000 costs about 19% of it.
- In July 2025, Joe Koch showed WKBN an 1,800-square-foot ranch at the Landings priced at $500,000. That is roughly twice the county's August 2026 average sale, and that ranch is more than a year old as a price example.
In the same WKBN report, Koch said the industry could use some government help to bring that price down. So the builder himself does not present a $500,000 ranch as an entry-level product.
A buyer who sees "new" and "Austintown" in the same listing may expect a modest premium over resale. The numbers show a different product, one that starts at a land cost a first-time buyer would normally spend on a down payment and closing costs several times over.
Who that price works for
The prices fit a certain kind of buyer. Trisha Howe, executive director of the Home Builders & Remodelers Association of the Valley, told The Business Journal in June that the homes going up locally are a mix of smaller homes for older buyers and larger homes for families. She described the movement this way:
"Some people are downsizing and selling their homes and other people are buying new homes. Traditional families are moving out of their starter homes and moving forward with going into a larger home and a larger development."
Both groups she names, downsizers and families leaving starter homes, usually own a house already. Selling it gives them equity to put toward a $90,000 lot and a house on top of it. Howe also noted that new homes are smaller in square footage than they were about 20 years ago, the last time the association held a Parade of Homes. A smaller footprint is one way builders keep the total price in reach when the land costs this much.
Where a new build meets the resale buyer
This is why the Austintown building activity matters even to someone who has no plans to build. When an owner commits to a lot at the Landings or Lloyd Oaks, their current house usually goes on the market. That freed-up home is what the first-time buyer and the budget-minded move-up buyer are actually shopping for.
Koch put the general problem plainly to The Business Journal in March. Low supply means more people competing for fewer homes, and that pushes prices up. Recent county numbers fit that picture.
Mahoning County, MLS Now | July 2026 | August 2026 |
|---|---|---|
Homes sold | 248, up 5.5% from July 2025 | 203, down 16.1% from August 2025 |
New listings, year over year | Up 15.8% | Down 7.1% |
Average sale price | $258,804, up 7.3% | $260,181, up 7.7% |
Sales counts and new listings went in opposite directions from July to August. The average price rose by a similar amount both months. An average can move when a different mix of homes sells, so it is not a precise measure of what any one house is worth. Still, a year-over-year gain of more than 7% in two straight months points to steady pressure on existing-home prices.
For a resale buyer, each owner who moves into new construction adds one more existing home to a tight supply. These are small numbers. The Landings had 15 homes in phase one, and Lloyd Oaks has a handful of lots. They are not enough to shift county prices on their own. They do add listings in a market where listings are what buyers are short on.
Why the ground costs what it does
Builders point to a few reasons land is expensive here. Koch told WKBN that the 2008 and 2009 downturn wiped out much of the local pool of people who knew how to put in residential developments and build in volume. He also said federal wetland designations take away land where homes could otherwise go, and he has called for those rules to be eased. That is his view as a developer, and it explains part of why a finished lot is priced the way it is.
Momentum is building anyway. In that July 2025 report, a new road was going in at the Landings with 43 houses under construction, which WKBN reported as the most in 25 years. Across the region, the Youngstown-Warren Regional Chamber's housing council has set a goal of 1,000 new housing units over five years. That goal covers the whole region and every price point, not Austintown in particular. The Business Journal has tied new local demand partly to possible jobs from projects like Kimberly-Clark's. That plant is going up on land in Warren and Howland.
Questions to settle before choosing build or buy
If you are weighing a new build in Austintown against an existing home, these questions turn the lot price into a real decision:
- What is the all-in number? Ask the builder for a quote that combines the lot, the house and the site work. Compare that total with existing homes of similar size, not the lot price alone.
- Does your plan depend on selling first? Both groups Howe describes are selling a current home as they move. That makes the timing of your sale part of the construction plan.
- How long can you wait? Lloyd Oaks had no definite completion date in WFMJ's report, and the Route 46 subdivision is still described as a plan. A resale home can usually close on a schedule you know in advance.
- What does the same budget buy in resale? The county averaged $260,181 per sale in August 2026. Ask what that range buys in Austintown compared with Canfield or Boardman before you decide.
FAQ
Does a $90,000 lot price at The Landings at Boulder Creek include a house? No. The builder lists it as a homesite price. The house is priced separately.
Is the Route 46 subdivision near Chipper's Practice Range open? As of the March 2026 report, Koch Construction described it as a planned subdivision of roughly 100 houses. No lots are listed for it on the builder's site.
Are the county sales figures specific to Austintown? No. The MLS Now numbers cover all of Mahoning County and report average prices, not medians.
If you are trying to decide whether a new Austintown homesite or an existing house fits your budget and timing, I can help you line up a builder's all-in quote against recent resale numbers. That includes planning around a home you may need to sell first. Gameplanning, strategy, information gathering, honesty and solid experience from a real estate professional can make a huge difference when making these decisions. Reach out to Tibitha Matheney, Realtor, and let's connect.