Two-story brick-and-siding Colonial with an orange-red maple and curved bluestone walkway across its lawn.

Boardman’s Route 224 Is Changing as Oktoberfest Turns 50

Drive Route 224 through Boardman today and three restaurant sites where you may have eaten now house, or are expected to house, businesses different from those there a year ago. The Choolaah on Boardman-Poland Road is a First Watch now. The Taco Bell a little further down is getting gutted for a chicken finger chain that's never had a Mahoning Valley address. And the old Hot Dog Shoppe, a name a lot of longtime residents actually remember, is about to come down entirely for a Culver's.

Meanwhile, less than two miles away at Boardman Park, the Rotary Club is planning the annual event it has run every fall since 1976. Same park. Same Sunday format. Same $5 at the gate. This year marks the tradition’s 50th anniversary.

That's the actual story here. It's not that Boardman got some new restaurants, every township gets new restaurants. It's that an unusually specific stretch of one road has seen three restaurant sites change or prepare for change in roughly a year while the township's oldest recurring tradition has continued even as the event has grown.

What Actually Changed Along the Strip

Start with First Watch, because it's the one that's already open. The breakfast and brunch chain took over the former Choolaah space at 1051 Boardman-Poland Road, right next to Condado Taco and Starbucks, expanding the footprint to roughly 3,500 square feet with a covered patio and a bar seating over 160 people total. The company brought about 30 jobs with it and runs a "no night shift" model, meaning the doors close at 2:30 in the afternoon every day. If you've noticed the parking lot full at 9 a.m. on a Saturday and empty by dinner, that's why.

A little further along Route 224, the former Taco Bell is being reworked into a Layne's Chicken Fingers, the chain's first location anywhere in the Mahoning Valley. Layne's has locations scattered through the Cleveland and Pittsburgh markets but never one here, which makes this a genuine first rather than another regional chain filling a gap. As of this fall, no grand opening date has been announced, so it's the kind of thing residents are watching for rather than something already on the calendar.

The bigger change is happening where the Hot Dog Shoppe used to be. That building isn't being renovated, it's coming down. Boardman's Board of Zoning Appeals approved a conditional use permit in mid-July for a new Culver's on the site, drive-thru included, and demolition followed by new construction was expected to begin at the end of September. That puts ground-breaking right around now, which means the empty lot you might be driving past this week is the start of an entirely new building, not a renovation of the old one.

Three buildings. Three different concepts. All on the same road, all within about a year of each other. That's not a pace most people would guess for a single stretch of a township highway, and it's easy to miss if you're only clocking one restaurant change at a time instead of adding them up.

A Fourth Name, One Road Over

The restaurant math doesn't stop at Route 224. Red Rican, a Puerto Rican concept built by three brothers who started with a food truck before opening sit-down locations in Niles and Campbell, opened its third restaurant this year at 270 Boardman-Canfield Road. The brothers built the brand on loaded pork bowls, pastelillos and homemade desserts, and they've kept the food truck and a dessert trailer running at festivals and breweries even after going brick and mortar. Earlier this year they partnered with Birdfish Brewery on a Corona-style beer called Borikèn, sold on tap at their locations.

Boardman wasn't even the last stop. By late July, Red Rican had already announced a fourth location in Austintown, on Mahoning Avenue, meaning the Boardman restaurant is now the middle chapter of an expansion that's still going. That's worth knowing if you've eaten there recently and assumed it was a one-off addition. It's actually one piece of a business that's been adding a new Mahoning Valley address roughly every few months.

Add it up and Boardman has picked up four new restaurant names in a fairly tight window, First Watch, Red Rican, and soon Layne's and Culver's, while losing at least three longtime tenants along the way. For a township this size, that's a lot of storefront turnover to happen almost entirely on two connected roads.

The Fall Tradition That Has Lasted 50 Years

Now walk two miles over to Boardman Township Park, where the Rotary Club of Boardman is finalizing its 50th-anniversary Oktoberfest, set for Sunday, October 4, 2026, from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Admission is still $5 for adults, and kids 12 and under still get in free, the same pricing structure the club has used for years.

What started as a small craft show with roughly 50 vendors set up on a hill near a church in 1976 now regularly draws more than 150 vendors from as far as five states and pulls in over 10,000 visitors in a single day. The event is run entirely by volunteers, all 74 members of the Rotary Club, and every dollar collected goes back into the community rather than into any organizer's pocket. Past beneficiaries include Boardman Schools, Easter Seals, Habitat for Humanity, the Boy Scouts, Beatitude House, Boardman Community Baseball, the Salvation Army and the YWCA. The Boardman Rotary has kept that same distribution model in place for decades.

The format hasn't drifted either. The Boardman Spartan Marching Band still performs on the midway. The YMCA of Boardman still runs the kids zone. Live entertainment still happens at the Maag Pavilion. If you went to this event ten years ago, this year's version will feel almost identical, just bigger. That kind of stability is rare enough in any local institution that it's worth naming directly rather than treating it as background noise to a restaurant story.

What the Park Does for the Rest of the Season

Oktoberfest isn't the park's only fixed point this time of year. Boardman Park runs a fairly consistent holiday lineup once October ends, including a Christmas Tree Lane where the park sells live trees on select weekends in November and December, a drive-thru Winter Wonderland Holiday Lights display that runs from early December through the first week of January, and a Boardman Community Christmas Event in the Lariccia Community Center with hot chocolate, fire pits and holiday craft making. None of that programming has needed to reinvent itself year to year the way the restaurants along Route 224 have. You can check the current dates directly through Boardman Park's own events calendar, but the shape of the season rarely changes much from one year to the next.

That contrast is really the point. A resident who eats along Route 224 regularly is watching a genuinely fast rate of change, three anchor buildings changing hands or getting rebuilt within about a year, plus a fourth new name a road over. A resident who spends fall weekends at Boardman Park is watching the same festival continue to grow while carrying on a tradition the township has kept since the Ford administration. Both things are true about the same three-mile stretch of town at the same time, and neither one cancels the other out.

If you're trying to figure out why Boardman feels different lately even though the park's fall traditions have endured, that's your answer. It's not the park. It's the road that gets you there.

A Local Perspective, If You Ever Need One

I've lived and worked in this valley my whole career, and the kind of detail that makes a neighborhood feel different from one year to the next rarely shows up in a spreadsheet. It shows up in which building is under a tarp on your commute and which festival still smells exactly like it did when you were a kid. If you're ever curious about what's changing in your specific corner of Boardman, Canfield, Poland, Austintown or anywhere else in the Mahoning Valley, I'm always glad to talk it through. Tibitha Matheney has been tracking this valley long enough to know the difference between a trend and a coincidence. Let's Connect whenever you want to compare notes.

Work With Tibitha

Your dream home is within reach, and you don't have to navigate the journey alone. Receive personalized guidance and expert support every step of the way.

Follow Me on Instagram